Vartinis Case dropped due to the prescription

  • actual
  • 17:11 4 December 2023
  • |

ANKARA - Announcing its decision in the Vartinis Case, which was filed regarding the burning to death of 9 people from the same family in 1993, the court decided to drop the file on the grounds of prescription.

The case regarding the burning and murder of 9 people from the same family, whose houses were set on fire by soldiers on October 3, 1993, in the Vartinis (Altınova) town of Til (Korkut) district of Muş, continued to be heard at the Kırıkkale 1st High Criminal Court after the Supreme Court's reversal decision.

At the hearing, where Aysel Öğüt, the only survivor of the massacre, was present as a complainant, her husband Abdullah Öğüt, Peoples' Equality and Democratic Party (HEDEP) Mûş MP Sümeyye Boz, party's Law and Human Rights Commission Co-Spokesperson Nuray Özdoğan, Human Rights Association (İHD) MYK member Nuray Çevirmen, representatives of the Memory Center, Mûş Bar Association President Kadir Karaçelik, one of the lawyers on the case, lawyers who are members of the Ankara Bar Association and Özgür Yaldız, a member of the Association of Lawyers for Freedom (ÖHD).


At the hearing, the prosecution presented its prepared opinion to the court panel. The prosecution stated that the fugitive defendant Captain Bülent Karaoğlu, who ordered the burning of the village in the operation in which a soldier lost his life, should not be considered to be the sole authority, and requested that the file be dropped due to the prescription.


Speaking after the opinion, Wan Bar Association President Sinan Özaraz requested to participate in the file. Özaraz stated that a crime against humanity was committed in Vartinis and that crimes against humanity do not have prescription, and said that the opinion should not be accepted. Lawyers from the Ankara Bar Association, who took the floor after him, made similar statements and emphasized that there would be no prescription in this file, and requested participation in the case. Evaluating the requests, the court rejected the participation requests of Ankara and Wan Bar Associations due to the stage the file had reached.


Aysel Öğüt, to whom the committee spoke against the opinion, said: “All I want from you is justice. May my family's rights be ignored. My family was murdered in front of my eyes, I want this murderer to be caught. I leave my rights first to God and then to you."


Kadir Karaçelik, one of the lawyers in the case, stated that there has been a 30-year search for justice. Karaçelik said: “We had a procedural discussion for five hours in the first hearing of this case. We need to look at what this case means to us as citizens, lawyers and legal organizations. How will we defend these human rights when children die and people are massacred? You can only encounter such a fiction in a war movie. Aysel and her family mean something different to us. What Aysel went through is not something that people living in this country can remain indifferent to. We all know what kind of tragedy happened in Vartinis. This case is a case to be heard in Nazi Germany. We need to condemn Bülent Karaoğlu in the public conscience. The perpetrator was not searched clearly and was said to have 'escaped'. We do not agree with the statute of limitations decision because the act and action fall within the scope of crimes against humanity."


After evaluating the prosecution's arguments after the defenses, the court panel stated that 2 months had passed since the prescrıptıon and decided to drop the case file.

View More Articles

18:30 3 prisoners on hunger strike exiled
15:43 Femicide: 8 women murdered in 1 day
14:55 Iran massacred Kurdish kolbar
14:38 Repeated air strikes on Dêrik
14:34 No news from journalist Ahmet detained by KDP for 127 days
14:33 Hunger strike in prisons on its 94th day
14:00 Health violations experienced by 12 women prisoners
12:33 Solidarity call from DFG and TGS for Müftüoğlu
11:54 'Art creates a peaceful city'
11:52 Women found their identity in Northern and Eastern Syria
10:02 PIRHA reporter Keser arrested
18:50 Confidentiality order imposed on files of 3 journalists detained in Wan
12:31 Hunger strike in prisons on its 93rd day
12:22 'Solution' declaration signatories: Obstacles to Abdullah Ocalan must be abolished
12:14 Abdullah Ocalan's 55-year marathon: Dolmabahçe Agreement
11:24 Kurdish women's struggle for existence: Organization is changing
10:56 Journalists detained in Wan
21:00 Aktaş and Yavuzel were commemorated with a march
18:34 114 years in the footsteps of Rosa Luxemburg: The struggle has become global, we continue on our way
17:41 Bakırhan: We made a people's alliance against the JITEM alliance
17:05 Türkoğlu: We are going to March 8 with the motto 'Always resistance, always freedom'
16:16 Ban on Mount Gabar extended for the 5th time
16:15 It reveals that the child who was said to have committed suicide 19 years ago was murdered
16:14 219th issue of Xwebûn is out
16:13 No news from journalist detained by KDP for 125 days
16:09 Hunger in prisons on its 92nd day
18:58 Bayındır: If you want solution, the interlocutor is Abdullah Ocalan
17:55 'Democracy and Freedom' rally in Esenyurt
12:14 Jin Magazine's topic this week equal representation and co-chairship
12:12 Prisoners' protest its third month
12:05 No news from journalist detained by KDP for 124 days
11:56 What do NGOs think about the solution of the Kurdish issue?
11:37 There has been no news from Abdullah Ocalan for 36 months
11:26 Müftüoğlu's hearing on February 29: Lawlessness must end
11:25 Comes from England to support Justice Watch
17:31 No news from journalist detained by KDP for 123 days
17:09 Hunger strike in prisons on its 90th day
18:28 To AKP candidate who said 'We brought you peace': Where is peace, bread costs 10 liras!
18:00 Bakırhan: Neither Alexander nor the Persians passed these mountains, thieves never can
17:06 'We will rebuild ourselves and our cities'
12:05 Woman murdered in Sêwereg
12:01 'Operation' pressure on village guards in Qileban
11:59 Families apply to go to Imralı
11:34 No news from journalist detained by KDP for 122 days
11:33 Hunger strike in prisons on its 89th day
11:17 Murdered journalist Altun's mother: His pen was not left on the ground
16:37 Violations increased in Serhat and Karadeniz prisons: Abolished the isolation immediately
14:07 Medicines not given to ill prisoners
12:52 No news from journalist detained by KDP for 121 days
12:51 Hunger strike in prisons on its 88th day