'Special law' for İmralı on the agenda of Committee of Ministers

  • actual
  • 12:13 30 November 2021
  • |
img
ISTANBUL - At the meeting of the EC Committee of Ministers that will start today, the violation decision of the ECtHR regarding PKK Leader Abdullah Öcalan will be discussed. If it is determined that Turkey does not comply with the decision, some sanctions may be imposed on Turkey.
 
The Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe (EC UK) is meeting today in Strasbourg. In the meeting, which will last until December 2, the violation decisions of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) for PKK Leader Abdullah Öcalan and prisoners Hayati Kaytan, Emin Gurban and Civan Boltan, who are being held in İmralı Type F High Security Closed Prison, will be discussed. It is expected that the violation decisions about Selahattin Demirtaş, former Co-Chair of the Peoples' Democratic Party (HDP) and imprisoned businessman Osman Kavala, who are being held in Edirne Prison, will also be discussed at the meeting.
 
SANCTIONS
 
In the event that the decision of the ECtHR that the aggravated life sentence for Öcalan is in violation of Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), which prohibits torture and ill-treatment, is not implemented, some sanctions against Turkey may be imposed. Turkey's relations with the EC UK and its membership may also be a matter of debate.
 
VIOLATION DECISION PROCESS
 
The ECtHR decided that the aggravated life sentence for PKK Leader Abdullah Öcalan, who has been held in İmralı Type F High Security Closed Prison since August 15, 1999, is in violation of Article 3 of the ECHR, which prohibits torture and ill-treatment. Following this decision made on March 18, 2014, a violation decision was made for the prisoners Hayati Kaytan, Emin Gurban and Civan Boltan on the same issue. Despite the fact that 7 years have passed since the violation decision for Öcalan and other detainees, no action has been taken, which mobilized legal and human rights organizations.
 
Association of Lawyers for Freedom (ÖHD), Society and Law Research Foundation (TOHAV), Human Rights Association (İHD) and Human Rights Foundation of Turkey (TİHV) applied to the EC BK on 26 July, which oversees and implements the decisions made by the ECtHR. The committee put the issue on its agenda for the first time and decided to discuss the decision at the meeting to be held between 30 November and 2 December.
 
TWO SEPARATE NITIFICATIONS FROM TURKEY
 
Turkey made two separate notifications after the Committee brought the issue to the agenda. Turkey, which gave the first response to the application of human rights and law organizations on September 7, claimed that there has been no violation in Imrali since 2009. Turkey, on the other hand, ignored the findings and suggestions in the application regarding the "right to hope" and "change in the law on aggravated life sentence", which brought forward the possibility of the release of Öcalan and other detainees. It is noteworthy that Turkey only focused on the report prepared by the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture (CPT) on the physical conditions of Imrali in previous years. Since 2009, Öcalan and other detainees have been prevented from meeting with their families and lawyers for various reasons.
 
SPECIAL LAW
 
In the second statement that Turkey submitted to the Committee on October 7, with the title “Action Plan”, stating that Öcalan and other detainees do not have the right to 'parole', it accepted the “private law” practice in İmralı. In its statement, Turkey pointed to the "Öcalan 2" decision of the ECtHR, and claimed that after November 17, 2009, there was no "ill-treatment" in Imrali. It ignored the fact that since 2009, Öcalan and other detainees have been prevented from meeting with their families and lawyers for various reasons. In the notification, again pointing to the ECtHR decision, it was argued that the "improvements" made in Imrali in the period after November 17, 2009 were appreciated and the violation before 2009 was remedied. However, the application made to the ECtHR on behalf of PKK Leader Öcalan in 2011 regarding the detention conditions in İmralı was ignored.
 
 
MA / Ferhat Çelik 
 

View More Articles

06/07/2025
20:16 Abdullah Öcalan: We are entering a new phase
17:03 MKG: 7 women journalists detained, 2 arrested
15:34 DEM Party İmralı Delegation to meet President Erdogan tomorrow
15:04 DEM Party İmralı delegation meeting with Abdullah Öcalan end
14:02 Fire extinguished on Gabar Mountain
13:53 Young people met at the workshop: We will lead the construction of a democratic society
13:16 Committee to 'seize' Kurdish property in Afrin!
12:49 Untreated prisoner loses eye
12:09 I want to meet and discuss with Öcalan says Djemila Benhabib
11:54 JINNEWS June tally: 19 women and 1 child murdered
11:42 DEM Party delegation go to İmralı
10:24 Status demand to Kurdish language: We can play active rol in process
09:32 World’s eyes on PKK: Which parties and organisations to follow?
04/07/2025
16:17 ‘Öcalan's plan has the potential to stabilize the Middle East’
16:05 Forest Fire in Omerya Area
15:57 Fire in Gabar spreads over a wide area
13:24 Arrest warrant request for Tunc Soyer and 98 Others
12:05 137 people reffered to Court in İzmir
11:50 Families apply to İmralı Directorate
11:43 Visitation ban imposed on prisoners in Wan
10:50 IHRNGO Director: Aim of the repression is to prevent new protests
09:57 Youth to meet on agenda of ‘Peace and Democratic Society Process’
09:55 We are more hopeful than ever for national unity says KNK Co-chair
09:25 'There is no chance to postpone or delay the national congress'
09:24 'I want to visit Öcalan' campaign: The main goal is freedom of Öcalan
03/07/2025
16:34 What did the European delegation discuss at the 'Round Table'?
14:05 DEM Party convenes
14:04 DFG June report: 16 detentions, 6 arrests
12:34 Youth to organize 'Democratic Society Workshop'
11:04 Legal regulations are needed to make process permanent says CHP member
11:03 IHD Istanbul Branch Chair: Ill prisoners cannot wait for September-October
11:00 KJAR: We are fighting for free women and a democratic Iran
02/07/2025
16:16 People of Şirnex demand cancel of dam projects
13:45 Delegation from Europe demands immediate and unconditional release of Öcalan
11:44 Attack on Baloch women in Iran: 1 dead, 11 injured
11:12 Abdullah Öcalan sends message to European delegation
10:12 Women to convey demands on process to Parliament
09:27 Occupation continues in Serêkaniyê, Girê Spî, and Efrîn
09:21 Embargo continues in Makhmur: Hundreds of patients unable to access treatment
09:20 Health of ill prisoners worsens in Antalya prisons
09:19 ‘Workers must be the subject of the process’
09:18 Increased Pressure on Kurds in Iran: Demand for autonomy suppressed
01/07/2025
16:17 Details of the draft DEM Party to submit for the commission
15:15 European Delegation Visits DEM Party in Istanbul
15:07 Family of Rozerin Çukur Reacts to Constitutional Court Ruling: We could not find justice
13:09 Delegation from Europe submits petition to meet Abdullah Öcalan
13:00 Fatma Bostan Ünsal: Concrete legal and political steps must accompany peace rhetoric
11:50 Bar Association Chairs urge TBB to form legal monitoring committees
11:10 Seferi Yılmaz: Everyone must work for peace against war profiteers
09:39 Let’s hold firmly to the process says Writer Faik Tac