Del Ponte: UN failed, West betrayed the Kurds

  • actual
  • 10:47 16 November 2019
  • |
img

NEWS CENTER - Del Ponte said that the role of the UN in the war in Syria had actually to do only with humanitarian aid. The UN has done nothing to bring peace to Syria, she said.

 
ANF talked with Carla Del Ponte, former Swiss attorney general and a former member of the United Nations Independent International Commission of Inquiry on Syria, about the UN’s eight year practice on Syria, why the war crimes and crimes against humanity committed in Syria are not dealt with, the Turkish state’s presence in Syria and ongoing invasion attacks against North-East Syria and trial of ISIS members.
 
Ms Del Ponte, in spite of your important work, you resigned from the UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry on Syria in 2017. Why?
 
After five years in the commission, I had two reasons to resign. The first was that, despite our important work and reports, the UN Security Council did not establish an international court to investigate all war crimes committed in Syria. We wanted to get justice for the victims in Syria, but this was not allowed and in the sense, we failed.
 
Secondly, the existence of the Independent International Commission of Inquiry on Syria, was very important to reveal and clarify all the crimes committed on the field. But later these crimes were not pursued or an investigation against the perpetrators was not initiated as planned. I resigned to protest that this commission would not justify its existence and that the UN Security Council did not seek justice for the victims and crimes committed in Syria.
 
How do you assess the UN's role in the Syrian civil war?
 
The role of the UN in the war in Syria had actually to do only with humanitarian aid. The UN has done nothing to bring peace to Syria. The UN initially wanted to hold talks in Geneva, but failed. While the Syrian government did not want to participate in these talks, the opposition groups did not accept many things. Even worse, a little later ISIS and extremists began to emerge in Syria.
 
This situation was not taken into consideration at the early stage. The UN Security Council has not made major decisions to ensure peace in Syria. This did not surprise me because if the UN does not renew itself it will end up with less and less power. If we want to achieve peace in the world, an important institution like the UN must renew itself. Unfortunately, the UN cannot do more than providing humanitarian aid at this stage. I say the UN must definitely renew itself. But it is very difficult because some states are not in favour of this.
 
You talked about the war crimes carried out frequently in Syria both during and after your role in the commission, who carried out these crimes?
 
The experience I have gained from the work I have done in the conflict process has shown me that all parties have carried out war crimes and crimes against humanity in conflict or war environments.
 
As for Syria, the Syrian regime, dissidents and jihadist groups have all carried out war and crimes against humanity. As Commission, we have documento all the crimes carried out in Syria in the reports we prepared at that time and we have indicated who was responsible for them.
 
After 8 years of unsuccessful Geneva talks, the Syrian Constitutional Committee is meeting under the UN supervision. UN Special Representative in Syria Geir Pedersen, who led the meetings, considered this a success. Do you agree with him?
 
Unfortunately, I have not seen any success to date. Yes, meetings are currently being held in Geneva, but we haven't seen anything positive outcome yet. Although the regime participation in these meetings is positive, I would say that we should not expect a successful outcome of these meetings. 
 
As in the Geneva talks, the Kurds were not invited to the Syrian Constitutional Committee meetings, how do you evaluate this?
 
I don't know why the Kurds have not been invited. Kurds should be invited to these meetings and be active in these meetings. Kurds actively fought against ISIS alongside the US. But today the very US has given up on Kurds.The worst of this being that Kurds have been left alone to face the attacks carried out by Turkey. Kurds are facing a delicate process, but unfortunately, the international community is not interested in the problems faced by the Kurds.
 
How do you assess Turkey's role in the civil war in Syria?
 
Turkey took an anti-regime attitude at the beginning of the war. It opened its borders, allowing the opposition to cross into Syria, allowing them to go and support these groups. Later, Turkey got together with Russia, which is supporting Syria, and began to change its role in Syria.
 
Although the change in policy, it appears clear that Turkey, and especially Erdogan, will always consider the Kurds of Syria as a major problem. Using border security, Turkey has committed serious violations of international law, such as entering another country's territory. Entering into Syria made Turkey a direct partner in the war. This is a very serious violation of international law.
 
Today, the Turkish state is carrying out an occupation attack on North East Syria, hundreds of thousands of people have been displaced and hundreds of people have lost their lives. How do you evaluate this situation?
 
The Turkish state wants to expel the Kurds from the region, using border security as a reason for it, while this has never been a problem or a threat. Against this background, what surprised me most was the fact that the international community, and especially the UN, did not take a clear position against Turkey violation of international law. What’s more, the fact that they did not protect Kurds from Turkey attacks made me very sad and angry. The situation for the Kurds is very, very bad, and the international community and the UN have to intervene.
 
Do you mean the West has betrayed the Kurds?
 
Yes, definitely. This is a very bad situation. I think there should be a solution to the situation of the Kurds in a very short time. But I'm sorry, it's not being done. It is unacceptable to leave the Kurds alone where there is a solution to this situation. An acceptable solution should be found.
 
Everyone says that Turkey has violated international law in front of everyone’s eyes, yet somehow the international community or the UN prefers to remain silent on this situation, why?
 
Good question. But I'm sorry I don't know the answer. I can say this: politics and interests have prevented important tasks such as the protection of the victimized peoples, international law and human rights.
 
Do you think Turkish President Erdoğan, or Turkey are responsible of war crimes in Syria?
 
As I said before, I think the Turkish state and Erdoğan are committing war crimes in Syria. Syrian territory is being occupied with some groups, and today, crimes are committed in North East Syria. An investigation should be launched about this, but unfortunately this has not been done for 8 years and there is no search for justice.
 
What should be done against these war crimes?
 
First, the UN Security Council should establish an international court. But Russia, as before, continue to oppose this. 
 
Could an International Criminal Court prosecute Erdoğan?
 
The UN Security Council cannot initiate an investigation without the approval of the ICC because we know that Turkey has signed the Treaty of Rome. The UN Security Council must therefore make a decision for this to happen.
 
There is much talk about the help provided by Turkey to jihadist groups in Syria. What would you comment on this?
 
Yes, the first years of the war, Turkey was doing it openly. But after agreeing with Russia, it began to change its position. At first, it was helping many jihadists groups, for example, allowing fighters to pass, sending weapons, and supporting them.
 
Which jihadist groups was this support provided for?
 
I cannot distinguish which groups exactly it has provided help but at first it was for al-Nusra and some other groups. This is no secret, everyone knows it anyway.
 
Can the Syrian Kurds take the war crimes committed against them to the International Criminal Court?
 
Unfortunately, I am of the opinion that Kurds will not have such a right because they don’t have a state. These crimes could be taken to the Hague though. Turkish presence on Syrian lands is a violation of international law. Kurds may not be able to do this directly but Syria, as a state, could take the crimes committed by the Turkish state in its territory to the Hague.
 
Another important issue is that thousands of ISIS members continue to be held in detention centers under the Autonomous Administration control. Western states do not want to take back these mercenaries. How would you comment on this?
 
First of all, I believe that European states have to take back their citizens and subject them to investigation. to my way of thinking, them not wanting to do this, is wrong. We know that Kurds have arrested quite a number of jihadists and terrorists but unfortunately the Kurds don’t have a judicial power to bring them to justice under these circumstances. It is a great problem to put all this burden on the Kurds.
 
I do know that Kurds are faced with big trouble because of this situation. We had informed the Security Council on this matter while I worked for the commission but that yielded no results either, I am afraid. The European Union should finally find a solution. Every state must make a decision but they don’t want this. This attitude, in my opinion, is just a great mistake.
 
Don’t you think that an international tribunal could be established in North-East Syria for the trial of these mercenaries? Kurds also have such a demand.
 
That is indeed possible but this decision must be taken by the UN security Council. This is a political situation as much as it is possible. Still, an international tribunal could well be established outside of Syria to bring those people to justice.

View More Articles

04/07/2025
16:17 ‘Öcalan's plan has the potential to stabilize the Middle East’
16:05 Forest Fire in Omerya Area
15:57 Fire in Gabar spreads over a wide area
13:24 Arrest warrant request for Tunc Soyer and 98 Others
12:05 137 people reffered to Court in İzmir
11:50 Families apply to İmralı Directorate
11:43 Visitation ban imposed on prisoners in Wan
10:50 IHRNGO Director: Aim of the repression is to prevent new protests
09:57 Youth to meet on agenda of ‘Peace and Democratic Society Process’
09:55 We are more hopeful than ever for national unity says KNK Co-chair
09:25 'There is no chance to postpone or delay the national congress'
09:24 'I want to visit Öcalan' campaign: The main goal is freedom of Öcalan
03/07/2025
16:34 What did the European delegation discuss at the 'Round Table'?
14:05 DEM Party convenes
14:04 DFG June report: 16 detentions, 6 arrests
12:34 Youth to organize 'Democratic Society Workshop'
11:04 Legal regulations are needed to make process permanent says CHP member
11:03 IHD Istanbul Branch Chair: Ill prisoners cannot wait for September-October
11:00 KJAR: We are fighting for free women and a democratic Iran
02/07/2025
16:16 People of Şirnex demand cancel of dam projects
13:45 Delegation from Europe demands immediate and unconditional release of Öcalan
11:44 Attack on Baloch women in Iran: 1 dead, 11 injured
11:12 Abdullah Öcalan sends message to European delegation
10:12 Women to convey demands on process to Parliament
09:27 Occupation continues in Serêkaniyê, Girê Spî, and Efrîn
09:21 Embargo continues in Makhmur: Hundreds of patients unable to access treatment
09:20 Health of ill prisoners worsens in Antalya prisons
09:19 ‘Workers must be the subject of the process’
09:18 Increased Pressure on Kurds in Iran: Demand for autonomy suppressed
01/07/2025
16:17 Details of the draft DEM Party to submit for the commission
15:15 European Delegation Visits DEM Party in Istanbul
15:07 Family of Rozerin Çukur Reacts to Constitutional Court Ruling: We could not find justice
13:09 Delegation from Europe submits petition to meet Abdullah Öcalan
13:00 Fatma Bostan Ünsal: Concrete legal and political steps must accompany peace rhetoric
11:50 Bar Association Chairs urge TBB to form legal monitoring committees
11:10 Seferi Yılmaz: Everyone must work for peace against war profiteers
09:39 Let’s hold firmly to the process says Writer Faik Tac
08:32 Tatvan festival: We women are ready for process
08:27 Operation against CHP members in Izmir: Tunç Soyer detained
30/06/2025
17:00 Amed Ecology Assembly: Let's defend nature with communes
14:54 Women's festival on its second day
14:15 Kerim Boran releases
11:46 Mothers: Unity must be achieved
10:57 People want to meet Abdullah Öcalan to come to Turkey
10:42 Civil society organisations call on government to take steps
10:14 4 years since the Istanbul Convention cancelled: We will not give up
09:26 Presidential pardon for ill prisoner Boran
29/06/2025
15:24 Struggle of the Kurdish people will end in victory says DBP Chair Bayındır
14:21 'Women should be involved in process'
13:48 Labour in Democratic Society Workshop: Let’s be builders, not watchers